The Decemberists’ Beautiful World

Read our review of The Decemberists’ show at Hamer Hall


The Decemberists –

Hamer Hall Melbourne Australia 29 March 2016


Perfect acoustics.

That’s my number one wish, once I’ve forked out the cash for a live show.  I can put up with lousy seats (or the lack of them), poor vantage points, people talking (well, almost!), short shows, costly admission and lack of artists’ communication on stage.

A few days before at Melbourne’s Hamer Hall, I had witnessed Calexico and was disappointed by the fact that, while I could hear every word spoken by lead singer Joey Burns, I could not make out many words he sung.  Fortunately I knew a lot of the lyrics anyway, but it did detract from my enjoyment of seeing a favourite band at a venue renowned for its audio quality.

No such problems for The Decemberists at the same venue on Easter Tuesday.  This Bluesfest sideshow was an acoustic delight.

And so it was from the beginning.  Lead singer and songwriter Colin Meloy walked alone to the microphone, acoustic guitar in hand and started with the beautifully appropriate ‘The Singer Addresses His Audience’, the opening track of the band’s latest release What a Terrible World, What a Beautiful World.  The rest of the players then quietly entered and rode the song to a splendid crescendo.

What followed was an utter delight as this indie folk outfit from Portland Oregon showcased four other songs from their latest release and took material evenly from most of their earlier albums.  I last saw The Decemberists on a smaller stage at the New Orleans’ Jazz and Heritage Festival in 2011 and was taken by their musicianship, quirky songs and daring sense of fun.  Tonight, I was struck by the fact that their footprint was now much bigger, with two albums released with considerable critical acclaim since then and an equipment inventory that showed they meant business.

The band members are incredible players without overly drawing attention to themselves.  Chris Funk (guitars etc.), Nate Query (bass), Jenny Conlee (keyboards) and John Moen (drums) are also members of the fascinating ‘new grass’ outfit Black Prairie and they carry out whatever they turn their minds to with ease.

But the centrepiece clearly is Meloy, whose voice is strikingly good.  In a strange sort of way, he reminds me of Michael Stipe of REM.  Vocals so rich and resonating, articulation so complete that he would make an English teacher smile.  Lyrically, he is an astute and wry observer of humanity.

There were many highlights – ‘Down by the Water’, ‘The Rake’s Song’ and ‘Cavalry Captain’ come to mind instantly.  Also, there were plenty of local references such as a burning cover of The Hoodoo Gurus’ ‘Death Defying’ and an amusing exchange featuring Moen’s new pair of Blundstone boots.  More rollicking fun ensued with an epic version of ‘The Mariner’s Revenge Song’ featuring a large and delightful toothy whale prop.

Three encores were met with standing ovations which capped off a memorable night, a triumph for a band whose shadow continues to grow rapidly.

For The Decemberists’ completists, here is the set list


  1. The Singer Addresses His Audience *
  2. Cavalry Captain*
  3. The Wrong Year*
  4. Hank Eat Your Oatmeal / Calamity Song##
  5. Rox in the Box##
  6. Here I Dreamt I Was an Architect#####
  7. Make You Better*
  8. Down by the Water##
  9. Carolina Low*
  10. Better Not Wake the Baby*
  11. Culling of the Fold####
  12. O Valencia!####
  13. 16 Military Wives*****

Encore 1:

  1. Prelude***
  2. The Hazards of Love 1 (The Prettiest Whistles Won’t Wrestle the Thistles Undone)***
  3. A Bower Scene***
  4. Won’t Want for Love (Margaret in the Taiga)***
  5. The Rake’s Song***
  6. The Hazards of Love 4 (The Drowned)***

Encore 2:

  1. Death Defying (Hoodoo Gurus cover)
  2. The Mariner’s Revenge Song*****

Encore 3:

  1. Dear Avery##


*What a Terrible World, What a Beautiful World

##The King Is Dead

***The Hazards of Love

####The Crane Wife


#####Castaways and Cutouts


USA11 123 colin meloy

Colin Meloy – JazzFest New Orleans 2011



Read our review of The Decemberists’ show at Hamer Hall

Read our review of The Decemberists’ show at Hamer Hall

Read our review of The Decemberists’ show at Hamer Hall







(Visited 96 times, 1 visits today)

Author: Rob Dickens

Share This Post On
468 ad


  1. I saw them at Bluesfest and I thought their sound there was sensational. Great show!

    Post a Reply

Leave a Reply